Reading time

Healthcare Disinfection Crisis in Hautes-Pyrénées


Dental disinfection lapse at Hautes-Pyrénées exposes 5k to Hepatitis & HIV risks since 2006. Incident underscores need for strict sterilization and timely communication. Dive deeper into infection prevention in our article.

Infection prevention is a cornerstone in maintaining the highest standards of healthcare. Ensuring a sterile environment is critical in preventing the spread of infections, safeguarding both patient and staff health. In a startling disclosure that recently came to light, around 5,000 individuals who underwent dental procedures at certain hospital centers in the Hautes-Pyrénées region are now being urged to get tested for Hepatitis B, C, and HIV. This serious healthcare concern stems from a lapse in the disinfection of dental equipment used during treatments. The issue, dating as far back as 2006 for some patients, was uncovered following a professional practice review, which was triggered by a similar disinfection deficit incident at a Lyon hospital earlier this year.

The patients from the hospital centers of Tarbes-Lourdes-Bagnères-de-Bigorre in Hautes-Pyrénées have been receiving letters since the beginning of October, urging them to undergo necessary screenings. The letters signed by the interim director, Anne Ribeiro, highlighted a "very low risk" of infectious disease transmission due to the sterilization defect. However, the late detection and subsequent communication have left many in a state of shock and disbelief. Patients took to social media expressing their dismay, questioning the delay in notification, especially those whose treatments took place several years ago.

Christelle, a concerned parent whose child had a dental procedure in 2012, voiced her distress saying, "I am surprised, angry, and scared." Similarly, Viviane, a 61-year-old resident of Tarbes, was bewildered to learn about the disinfection mishap nearly 17 years post her treatment, raising valid concerns on the delayed communication.

This disinfection lapse is not an isolated incident, with similar occurrences reported in Rouen and Lyon, pointing to a broader national issue. Severine Lalanne, in charge of quality and risk management at the Bagnères-de-Bigorre hospital, acknowledged the problem with the disinfection of rotary instrument holders used in dental care. She explained that although the instruments were disinfected, the process wasn't thorough due to a deviation from the manufacturer's protocol aimed at preventing equipment damage, which unfortunately led to the sterilization defect.

The French healthcare system, admired globally, now faces a moment of reckoning. This incident underscores the critical importance of adherence to disinfection protocols to forestall potential cross-contamination and safeguard public health. Moreover, it accentuates the need for a robust monitoring mechanism and transparent, timely communication to uphold trust and ensure patient safety.

The Hautes-Pyrénées sterilization incident accentuates the imperative nature of strict infection prevention protocols in healthcare settings. It’s through rigorous sterilization practices and innovative solutions that we can fortify our defense against infections, ensuring a safe and trustworthy healthcare ecosystem for all.

With the innovative solutions offered by UV Smart, such as the UV Smart D25, the concerns over equipment damage during disinfection are a thing of the past. Unlike traditional methods, UV Smart's products ensure thorough high-level disinfection without the use of chemicals or consumables, promising a safe, traceable, automated and efficient solution to uphold the highest standards of hygiene in healthcare settings.

Want to learn more? Check out the following article on infection prevention in healthcare settings.

France 3 Regions. (2023). 5,000 patients potentially contaminated due to sterilization defect: Hepatitis and HIV testing advised. Retrieved from

Share article:

ECD in the media, COVID-19

Radboud buys ECD

First CE certification for UV Smart